Transport Insights

The transport stories you won't see in the industry-friendly media

Author

Chris Ames

Cover-up, spin and defensiveness do not breed confidence

The revelation that the report into the smart motorway camera fiaso identifies 10 missed opportunities to get on top of the problem, alongside news of a new problem, is a classic example of Labour picking a day to bury bad news and of the complacency, incompetence and defensiveness that we have come to expect from National Highways.

The Daily Mail’s David Churchill reports:

Labour was accused of trying to bury the news by slipping the report out today while all eyes in Westminster were on the release of the Milburn report to tackle youth unemployment.

Ministers have been sitting on it since July after Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander ordered it in January this year.

This government has a record of sitting on bad news, for example the POPE reports on smart motorways and the shelving of multiple local authority road upgrade schemes.

Both National Highways and ministers have also tried to play down the significance of the issue, including the spin in yesterday’s statement to Parliament from roads minister Justin Madders:

This error affected cameras on around 0.2% of all roads in England

It isn’t really the point; the strategic network is only about 2.4% of the English road network and smart motorways are a further fraction of that. They also rely on people complying with speed limits and Red Xs. Without that, they are not in any way smart.

Although Madders referred to an anomaly affecting the interaction between “some variable speed cameras and signage on the strategic road network in England”, it looks to me as if it was all of the HADECS3X cameras, which are the cameras on the smart motorway network and have capability to enforce Red X violations.

And, as the Westall report says:

it was believed to have affected 154 HADECS3X cameras across 22 police force areas in England, causing 2,650 erroneous camera activations between 2021 and 2025

Madders also had to reveal that “extensive technical and operational testing” had uncovered

a potential further issue with how these cameras may activate in specific circumstances, originating from the same 2019 upgrade.

And that

The Home Office has decided to revoke the camera system’s type approval status

And

The camera system was procured by National Highways on the basis that it maintained its Home Office type approval. Since that is no longer the case, National Highways is ending its contractual relationship to use the cameras for enforcement with the device supplier, Verra Mobility, and is considering all further commercial and legal options that may be appropriate.

The Westall report goes through all of the complacency, incompetence and defensiveness that led to National Highways (and others) missing 10 opportunities to get on top of the problem between the first report of an issue and the public announcement in December 2025.

It notes:

From the point in January 2025 when NH was first made aware of an issue, intervention and escalation points were missed, highlighting a series of issues that inform the recommendations in this report:

  • Limited use of data and evidence delayed the response.
  • Incorrect assumptions about the cause and scale.
  • Voices not heard.
  • A lack of pace and ownership in the response.
  • Failure to adhere to internal processes, including crisis management.
  • Insufficiently visible leadership, governance and direction.
  • Ineffective communication with key stakeholders.
  • Limited strategic understanding of technology.

On the theme of governance, it concludes:

NH’s senior leadership did not grasp ownership of the issue as swiftly and decisively as it should have

Will heads roll? It looks like they already did. In January of this year, just two weeks after the Westall report was launched, National Highways chief executive Nick Harris announced his resignation.

It remains to be seen whether the company – which we own – will become less complacent, incompetent and defensive under new leadership.

One response to “Cover-up, spin and defensiveness do not breed confidence”

  1. […] My guess is that it is no longer reviewing proposals at all but is merely waiting for a day to bury bad news. […]

    Like

Leave a Reply


Discover more from Transport Insights

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

One response to “Cover-up, spin and defensiveness do not breed confidence”

  1. […] My guess is that it is no longer reviewing proposals at all but is merely waiting for a day to bury bad news. […]

    Like

Leave a Reply